Monthly Archive for June, 2010

Don’t let this happen to us

A recent story in the New York Times reveals how a fight over immigration is creating a deep divide in a small Nebraska town. Its citizens have forced a referendum on an ordinance that would require businesses and landlords to check immigration status.

Residents who have spoken out about the proposal β€”for and against β€” say they have become targets for harassment as tensions mount. One woman’s cat was shot, and another had a rock thrown through her window. Immigrants, even documented ones, say they no longer feel welcome.

People living anywhere in the United States without legal status is a problem, but it seems that much of the controversy in this town is driven by fear of foreigners. Residents complain of hearing Spanish in Wal-Mart and needing interpreters at school events. They say immigrants are driving up crime, though there are no statistics broken down by race and ethnicity to prove their suspicions.

When I was a news reporter, I frequently heard identical complaints in North Carolina communities. People felt threatened by seeing Spanish signs outside businesses and didn’t like not being able to understand their fellow shoppers at Wal-Mart. They talked of immigrant-led crime waves, when statistics showed that crime in their communities had decreased.

They had started thinking of immigrants as hostile invaders rather than human beings.

Here in North Carolina, let’s not allow fear and anger to rip apart our communities. Let’s work together to recognize our common humanity, and make that the foundation for finding a solution to the problem of illegal immigration.

Does immigration make our communities safer?

We frequently hear about murders, assaults and home invasions perpetrated by immigrants. Leaders in Arizona have cited such crimes as the reason for their new law requiring police officers to check immigration status.

But an interesting report today from the Associated Press reveals that, perhaps, the specter of violent crime committed by immigrants has been overblown. The story said that the four big cities with the lowest crime rates β€” San Diego, Phoenix, El Paso and Austin β€” are in high-immigration states along the Mexican border. And it showed that Border Patrol agents face far fewer assaults than cops.

Examinations of crime rates across the country have shown similar trends. Communities with lots of immigrants are often safer. In Johnston County, North Carolina, where the sheriff has complained of immigrants committing murder, rape and robbery, violent crime rates have fallen sharply since the county became a magnet for immigrants about a decade ago.

Of course, illegal immigration has caused problems in our country. But the popular image of immigrant as violent criminal has unfairly stained all immigrants, in North Carolina and around the country. An entire group of people have come to be seen as a menace.

This misconception is an example of what happens when charged rhetoric replaces true understanding. Uniting NC believes that, when we come together and share our stories, we will see that no one is more prone to commit a crime because of the language he speaks or the country where she was born.